Are the American Idol Judges Too Nice?

PEOPLE's TV critic doesn't exactly miss Simon Cowell - but somebody's got to cut through the goo

Source: http://feeds.people.com/~r/people/headlines/~3/PVf3o1XjExQ/0,,20481499,00.html

Anne Marie Kortright April Scott Arielle Kebbel Ashanti Ashlee Simpson Ashley Greene Ashley Olsen